We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page — at no extra cost to you. Here’s how we make money.
One of these is a well-funded brand you’ve seen advertised. The other is a smaller carrier most owners meet only when a comparison tool surfaces it.
That asymmetry is exactly why the comparison is worth doing carefully — because “bigger” and “better for your dog” are different claims, and only one of them is easy to verify.
This is general information, not veterinary or financial advice. Always confirm coverage details directly with your insurer and consult your vet for diagnosis and treatment decisions.
What Each One Is
Pumpkin sells comprehensive accident-and-illness coverage with reimbursement at 80% or 90% only, annual deductibles from $100 to $1,000, and annual limit tiers including unlimited. Its notable design choice is removing the 70% reimbursement option — the tier most likely to leave an owner badly short on a large claim. Full detail in our Pumpkin review.
Odie is a smaller US carrier offering accident-and-illness plans with a wellness option, generally positioned on price and simplicity. Our Odie review covers it on its own terms.
The honest framing: Pumpkin competes on product design, Odie competes on price and accessibility.
Size Is a Real Variable, and 2026 Proved It
There’s a factor almost no comparison lists, and 2026 made it concrete: will this company still want your business in three years?
Nationwide — one of the largest pet insurers in the US — moved to non-renew roughly 100,000 policies in 2025, citing veterinary cost increases. A federal class action followed in June 2025. We wrote about why that matters in our Nationwide review.
The reason it matters here is mechanical. If your car insurer drops you, your car is as insurable tomorrow as it was yesterday. Pet insurance doesn’t work that way: everything diagnosed while you were covered becomes a pre-existing condition at the next carrier. A non-renewal doesn’t return you to the market — it returns you to the market minus whatever you’d been claiming for.
So carrier continuity is a genuine buying criterion. But note which way the Nationwide episode cuts: the company that exited at scale was the big one. Size is not the same as commitment to the book. Judge each carrier on what it does, not on how familiar the logo is.
How to Actually Compare Them
Forget brand. Run the same four checks on both, in this order:
- Configure both identically — same deductible, same reimbursement percentage, same annual limit — and only then compare price. A quote page default is not a comparison.
- Check the reimbursement floor. Pumpkin won’t let you go below 80%. If Odie offers 70% and you select it to save money, you are buying a materially different policy, not a cheaper version of the same one.
- Ask both about curable pre-existing conditions in writing, by condition. For a dog with anything in the record, this single rule can outweigh every price difference — see curable pre-existing conditions.
- Compare orthopedic waiting periods. It’s the longest clock in any policy and the one that decides breed-linked claims — waiting periods.
You might be thinking: surely the bigger company pays claims more reliably. There’s no mechanism that guarantees it. Claims handling is a function of the administrator and the policy language, not of marketing budget. Read reviews of the claims process specifically, not of the brand.
Where Each One Fits
Pumpkin fits the owner insuring a breed with concentrated hereditary risk who wants a configuration that can’t be accidentally weakened, and who is planning a long horizon rather than a cheap year. The reimbursement floor and the $1,000 deductible headroom are the reasons, not the advertising.
Odie fits the owner for whom the practical alternative is no coverage at all, or who has priced both at identical configurations and found Odie meaningfully cheaper for that specific dog in that specific state.
Neither fits if your dog’s risk is one expensive chronic condition — Trupanion’s per-condition deductible restructures that problem — or if you want a deductible that decays with claim-free years, which is Embrace territory.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Odie a legitimate pet insurer? Yes. It’s a smaller US carrier; the correct domain is getodie.com. Smaller doesn’t mean unsound, and 2026 showed that large doesn’t guarantee continuity either.
Is Pumpkin more expensive than Odie? Generally Pumpkin sits upper-middle on price. Compare at identical configurations before concluding — default quote settings differ between carriers and make comparisons meaningless.
Does either cover hereditary conditions? Comprehensive plans at both are expected to, subject to the standard rule that no symptoms appeared before your waiting periods ended. Enrolment timing decides it — when to buy for a puppy.
Which has better claims handling? Not something a comparison article can settle honestly. Read claims-process reviews for both, and confirm turnaround expectations before buying — how to file a claim.
The Bottom Line
Brand recognition is the least useful input you have here, and 2026 gave the clearest possible demonstration of why.
Price both at the configuration you’d actually buy — 90% reimbursement, a deductible you could pay tomorrow, a limit that survives one bad year — then ask each the curable-conditions question in writing. Whichever answers better for your specific dog wins, regardless of which name you’d heard before.
The full field is in the 2026 comparison.
Sources & Methodology
Pumpkin’s reimbursement, deductible and annual limit options reflect its published plan terms as of 2026, cross-checked against Pawlicy Advisor carrier data. Odie details reflect its published coverage pages; the correct domain (getodie.com) was confirmed directly, an earlier assumed domain having proved not to exist. The 2025 Nationwide non-renewal of approximately 100,000 policies and the June 2025 federal class action are drawn from contemporaneous reporting. This article makes no claim about pending litigation. We have no commercial relationship with either carrier, and neither reviewed this article.
Last reviewed and updated: September 2026